PortlandOnline

POL Government Elected Officials Commissioner Amanda Fritz Blog
Comments on PGE Park deals - Printable Version - July 24, 2009 - 0 Comments

Below is my speech at the vote on 7/23/09, following the hearing on the latest version of the proposed predevelopment agreement to renovate PGE Park for Major League Soccer. I received a copy of the proposal at the hearing.  Mayor Adams's office had provided us with a similar earlier version, except for amendments on Sustainability and Fair Wages.  Commissioner Saltzman improved the deal with an amendment requiring the stadium to meet LEED Silver standards for green buildings.  Both my amendments failed, to improve conditions for workers and to require the team corporation rather than the City's Spectator Fund to pay fair wages.  A substitute amendment by Commissioner Leonard passed, stating that the corporation operating PGE Park has to follow the law (state and federal labor law).

 

There was some discussion regarding whether the citywide taxpayers of Portland are at risk with this deal.  The assertion was made that most Spectator Funds come from people who do not live in Portland - visitors paying hotel/motel taxes, and people from elsewhere watching sports games.  First, as noted below, the General Fund of the City of Portland backs the new debt if Spectator Funds decline, for instance if the Portland Trailblazers leave town when their current contract expires in 2025.  Also, the City Council is responsible for ensuring all taxes, fees, and rates are spent wisely, for the purposes intended.  The deal for soccer at PGE Park has basketball and hockey fans subsidizing MLS, and leaves the Beavers without a home.  It leaves little money available for upgrades and maintenance to the Rose Garden and Memorial Coliseum.  It borrows money at 9% using the fans' fees, and gives the MLS franchise a discount on the amount pre-paid for future years' rent -- the discount is 8% in this deal, compared with 6% in a deal for affordable housing the Council passed earlier in the afternoon.  In any proposal before Council, we should consider not only, "is this a good plan?", but also, "what else could we do with that money in that fund?"  We do not have an infinite amount of money to spend on anything.  We do not have an infinite amount of money in the Spectator Fund.  There should have been more consideration of what else the Spectator Fund money will be needed for.  I greatly appreciate those who took the time to come to the hearing to remind the Council about the need to fund improvements at Memorial Coliseum.

 

My comments:

 

On the surface, there is much to like about the latest agreement.  It doesn’t require the use of Urban Renewal Funds.  It is paid for through user fees, prepaid rent, and private contributions.  I was truly open to getting to the point of supporting the final agreement, despite my intention to vote against the competitive bidding exemption and granting of a sole source contract to Peregrine.  I especially appreciate Mayor Adams and his staff keeping my staff and me informed as the proposals changed as best they could. I assume his staff looked into my proposal to increase ticket taxes for soccer games at PGE Park more significantly, and found some reason that would not work.  Mayor Adams has set the expectation that reasonable people can disagree without being disagreeable, and I am grateful for his leadership on the Council. 

 

I am concerned about the issues raised by neighbors in Goose Hollow especially sightline concerns.  I am glad the parking structure issue is clarified.

 

However, now that I have looked at the details of the new deal and the proposal just doesn’t pencil out. 

 

The use of Zero Coupon Bonds is troubling. 

The agreement requires the use of these Bonds at a high rate of interest.  The price on the ledger is $11 million, but the borrowing will actually cost over $44 million.   The use of zero coupon bonds was of concern in the previous proposal, and remains so.  Interest rates at 9% will be high especially in this economic climate.  The bonds may be hard to sell.  These bonds are necessary because there is no money available in the Spectator Fund for payments on additional bonding for the first seven years, until the Rose Garden bonds are paid off.  Even after which, the cash flow of the Spectator Fund is reduced for another six years when the existing PGE Park bonds will be paid off.  The outcome of this is the back loading of the debt payments, resulting in the $11 million to be borrowed costing the Spectator Fund $44 million by the time these bonds are paid off in 2035. 

 

I cannot support borrowing money at high rates of interest to pay for a sports stadium, essentially taking out a second mortgage on the existing debt.

 

I believe this deal still puts the City’s General fund at risk

$27 million of that $44 million debt incurred through the use of Zero Coupon Bonds is due after 2025.  The significance of this is that until 2025, user fees from the Blazers are personally guaranteed by Paul Allen.  In 2025, the City’s agreement with the Blazers ends and must be renegotiated.  In a worst case scenario, the Blazers could walk away from Portland, with no recourse for the City of Portland, leaving a $27 million debt with no way to pay for it except through general funds.  This does not protect the City’s general fund, which was one of the conditions of the Stadium Task ForceThe Task Force requirement is not being met.

 

The City will receive no cash flow from PGE Park for 21 years

The deal proposes to capitalize the rent payments for the years 2017 through 2038 and to use those funds to provide $12 million towards the renovation of PGE Park,    When the City is  incurring annual expenses related to PGE Park of $450,000 in 2017, increasing each year up to $730,000 in 2035, there will be no income from PGE Park to pay those expenses.  This is not a fiscally prudent approach to finances.  The reference to the visit of Burnley FC reminds me that the success of a soccer team franchise depends on the success of the soccer team on the field.  Only three of the current MLS teams made a profit last year,  The Resolution before us today states that MLS has economic benefits, which is not borne out by the evidence.

 

The City is continuing to subsidize the Fair Wage for Pergrines Employees

The agreement includes a City subsidy for providing living wages to PGE Park employees. The City of Portland will be paying nearly $5 million over the 25 years of the Operating Agreement to subsidize the wages of Mr. Paulson’s employees.  On July 9th, I was assured, in Council, by Commissioner Leonard and Merritt Paulson that the City would not need to subsidize the wages of PGE workers, and that instead those workers would be allowed to unionize.  The Stadium Task Force included in their report a requirement that Mr. Paulson pay his employees a Living Wage.  That Task Force requirement is not being met

 

Talking about the Task Force, their report also stated “Losing the baseball team is not an acceptable tradeoff for gaining a Major League Soccer team.”  Yet the future of baseball in Portland is in doubt, and the Council voted to decouple the deals.    The Task Force requirement is not being met.

 

As a City, we talk a lot about environmental sustainability, but we also need to focus on Financial Sustainability.  The bottom line is that PGE Park with the redevelopment being proposed is unsustainable.  It will not jump start the local economy. It will not create living wage jobs (except in this case those being subsidized by the City).  The deal is certainly better than the previous proposals, but it is still not a good deal for the taxpayers of Portland.  Even under the best possible scenario, the City’s costs to own and maintain PGE Park will never be close to self-supporting if we go forward with changing PGE Park from a multi-use stadium to a soccer-specific stadium. 

 

In any deal, we must evaluate who pays and who benefits.  At first glance, the use of Spectator Funds and private money seems to meet the test that those who benefit will pay.  But in order to assess whether it is or is not a good plan,  we need to discuss what other uses the Spectator Fund may be needed for, and whether it is appropriate to borrow money that may be needed to pay back the General Fund.  That is why I say again that the taxpayers of Portland are at risk with this deal.

 

A large percentage of the Spectator Fund is generated in the Rose Quarter, by tickets at the Rose Garden and Memorial Coliseum, and by parking revenues from the Rose Quarter garage.  I believe it is unwise to spend a large percentage of these revenues on PGE Park, for 15 games of soccer per year.

 

Mayor Adams is just beginning a task force to determine the future for Memorial Coliseum and the Rose Quarter.  We have an underutilized Coliseum that we are looking to repurpose.  While there are some Urban Renewal dollars available to redevelop the Rose Quarter, by eliminating the availability of the Spectator Fund, we reduce the funding sources available to modify Memorial Coliseum and develop the Rose Quarter.  We should not tie up the Spectator funds for 25 years before we determine the future of Memorial Coliseum and the Rose Quarter.  There is currently no way to assess the lost opportunity costs if we put all our Spectator Funds money in the PGE Park basket.

 

I am open to a big idea.  I am willing to invest substantial money, millions even, for an economic development proposal with substantial likelihood of long term benefits from major investments.  But there has to be a payoff for the investment for the general taxpayers of Portland, not a sweetheart deal to benefit a narrow group. 

 

I have been known from my days on the Planning Commission as someone who looks at the details.  Details that were in short supply, either not available or available only at the last minute and in some cases still unavailable.  Details matter.   And in this case, the details show that the agreement is still fiscally unwise.

 

  • We have no guarantee the PGE stadium improvements will be cost-effective and provide the amenities Portlanders want with a sole source non-competitive bid contract.

 

  • We may well lose the Beavers from Portland.

 

  • There is risk to the General Fund.  We will incur a $44 million in debt and a possible 27 million dollar shortfall in the year 2025.

  

  • There will be no income from PGE Park for 21 years and the spectator fund will essentially be locked up to fund this deal. Funds that the City needed support improvements to the Rose Garden and our beloved Memorial Coliseum.

 

  • We will spend nearly $5 million to subsidize wages for Mr. Paulson’s employees so that they can earn a  living wage.     

 

The question is not whether this is a better deal for Portlanders than the previous proposal. The question is whether this is a good deal for Portland taxpayers and in my opinion it clearly is not.

 

I hope I'm wrong.  I hope it's wildly successful, and I will continue to look for improvements in the deal as it moves forward.

 

I vote No.

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________________________________________________

Proposed Amendment: 

 

Peregrine agrees to pay a Fair Wage, as defined by City Code, Chapter 3.99 to all employees, including any contracted employees, throughout the term of the Operating Agreement, with no subsidy by the City.   Peregrine agrees to provide a neutral setting for employees should they choose to attempt to organize.  

 

The amendment failed, despite Commissioner Saltzman's support.  Commissioner Saltzman and I were also the only two votes for a second amendment with just the second sentence.  Commissioner Leonard passed a substitute saying only that Peregrine will abide by federal and state labor laws.



Comments

Please review our Code of Conduct rules before posting a comment to this site. Report Abuse, please include specific topic and comment for the fastest response/resolution.

Post a Comment (Sign-In Required)

Blog Entries
Old Town Chinatown plans
Technology Oversight Committee Vacancy
Volunteers needed for Development Review Advisory Committee
How to schedule accommodations for meetings needing American Sign Language (ASL) interpreters
Portland's oversight of Landslide Hazards
Outstanding public school students win golf-related scholarships
Applications invited to join the Parks Board
Job opening for Compliance Officer/Community Liaison for the Police-Department of Justice Settlement Agreement
Mountain Biking in Forest Park and other Portland Parks
Forest Park Project Objective Screening Tool
Two new parks for East Portland
Volunteers needed for Golf Advisory Committee
Volunteers needed for Adjustment Committee and Historic Review Commission
Response to mistletoe selling without a permit
Winter Shelter options
Really really interesting statistics
Landlord Education Classes
Agreement reached on moving the historic Rayworth House
At-Large Members needed for Washington Park Transportation Management Association Board
Thoughts on Development Services and Parks, four weeks later
The Power of One
Speech at the vote on the City's 2013 - 14 budget
Response to Petition on Saving the Mounted Patrol
Reminder: Front desk job opening in my office, applications due Sunday 5 p.m.
Job opening in my Office
Portland Passes Protected Sick Leave ordinance
Volunteers needed for the Portland Utility Review Board
Draft Police Use of Force Policy revisions posted
Email of the Week, on gun violence
Comment period open for Regional Transportation investments
Foreclosure assistance that works
Earned Sick Leave forum and process
Earned Sick Leave Proposal
Lower cost Landline Phone Service, Cell and Internet Options
NW Parking Plan - Proposed Amendments
Thankful for Street Roots, and local businesses
Feast for Southeast on Thanksgiving Day
Comments regarding Department of Justice Settlement Agreement
City Budget Office, Next Steps
OHSU Magnet Celebration
City Budget Office proposal
City moves further into the 21st Century
Sunday Parkways in East Portland
Transit Tickets for Oct 3 Stand Down Day for Veterans
Statement on Appeal of Frashour ruling
Cascade Aids Project walk
Feeling suicidal? Don't call 9-1-1. Call 503-97-23456
Central City Concern Celebrates 40th Anniversary of Hooper Program
Recycling Facility Tour
The Big Float 2012
Golden Leaf Education Foundation Fundraiser
Honkin' Huge Burritos Day
City Commits to Formalize Relationships with Tribal Partners
Police Bureau Recruiting Community Police Officers
Submit Nominations for Awards! Plan a Party!
A family's experience with Autism
Help Prevent Homelessness for Larry
U.S. Conference of Mayors adopts Four Portland Initiatives
Expanded Coverage for Autism Treatment
City of Portland family's Kate Sinnott is Rose Festival Queen
Sunnyside Environmental School students visit City Hall
Community Empowerment Funding
Franklin HS graduation, and Kali Ladd on the City's Support for Education
Starlight Parade 2012
Comments on the new Urban Renewal Area for PSU
Visitors from Turkey
Promise Walk for Pre-eclampsia
Graffiti Cleanup with the 2012 Rose Festival Court
Lisa Jackson, EPA head, visits Portland
Why upcoming GirlStrength/WomenStrength classes matter
Congratulations, Portland Public Schools
NAMI Walk 2012
Walk to Work Day
2011 High School Graduation Rates
Buckman Pool - Budget meeting tonight
Chinese New Year Celebrations
Willamette Pedestrian Coalition Annual Meeting
Willamette River Recreation Strategy
PCC Future Connect Scholarship Program
Pirates of Madison High
President F.W. de Klerk's visit
Job openings in the 9-1-1 center
UNLESS
ANB Camp 49 Event
Publicizing Fundraisers
Introducing Dante J. James, Director of the Office of Equity and Human Rights
2011 By the Numbers - Report Card
East Portland Action Plan Annual Report
State Legislative Update 2/3/12
Piccolo Park Water Fountain Fundraiser
Love World Run
Earthquake Preparedness
Proposed Changes to the Portland Charter
Dr. Herman Frankel on the City Council's Corporate Personhood resolution
26th Annual Martin Luther King Jr. Skanner Foundation breakfast
TriMet budget survey
City Socks Drive Successful Again
56 days that changed my life
Iraqi Society of Oregon Cultural Integration Series Graduation
Great jobs in the Plumbers and Steamfitters trades
Hillsdale Mural Celebration
Poet Laureate Paulann Petersen
Willamette River Recreation Strategy - comments requested
Volunteers of America Home Free Event
Service Coordination Team Graduation
A young life lost - How you can help
Sisters of the Road Auction on now through Dec 1
Constitutional Rights of assembly and governance
Native American Heritage Month Marketplace
Patience and sleep-deprivation
City of Portland's bank use
Office of Equity and Human Rights Seeks Director - Job posting sent nationwide - please forward to qualified people who may be interested
Peaceful
Occupy Portland camps endanger vulnerable people
Central City Concern Homeless Action fundraiser
Emergency TEST this Wednesday Nov 9 - do NOT call 9-1-1
Spirit of Portland Awards
Clara Peoples, Mother of Junteenth in Portland
Margaret Carter PCC Technical Education Building Dedication
Standing on the Shoulders of Giants: Gretchen Kafoury
Occupy Portland
Letter Carriers Union Rally
Shine a Light on Addiction and Recovery
Changing Police policies and procedures
Please complete the Street Roots survey
City Internship, City Job
Improvements to the Time, Place and Manner ordinance governing liquor licensed establishments
Parkrose Centennial Celebration
Walk to End Alzheimers, Walk to Defeat ALS
Remembering 9/11/01, in Portland 2011
Gateway First Reponder Tribute and Citizen of the Year
Office of Equity Creation Hearing
Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber fundraiser dinner
Sunday in the sun
Saturdays are for Service
Portland should seek relief on EPA Drinking Water mandates
My vote against the bike rental project
Equity Office Creation Ordinance, Public Review Draft
Somali American Council of Oregon
MAX Red Line successful, Ten Years on
National Night Out
Delightful Sunday Events in SW, NE, SE and North Portland
Weeding the grounds, or building community pride?
East Portland Expo Extravaganza
World Cup Winners
Apply to Serve on the Public Involvement Advisory Council
BOEC User Board citizen members
Volunteers invited for Technology Oversight Committee, and for 2011 Charter Commission
Job Opening in my Office, and other City hiring opportunities
State Legislative Update 6/24/11
Knights of Rosaria
State Legislative Update 6/19/11
Juneteenth
State Legislative Update 6/10/11
State Legislative Update, end of May
Information on the Clean and Safe Program, for May 2011
City opens 2011 Spirit of Portland Award nominations
SB 346: Common Sense protections for callers to 9-1-1
The 9-1-1 computer: On time, under budget, and it works
Op-Ed in Street Roots on Street Performers
Vote daily to help Capitol Hill School
Parade Season kicks off on 82nd Avenue of Roses
State Legislative Update 4/29/11
Comments on JTTF Vote 4/28/11
Mid-term statistics
Hollyrood Kindergartners Cuter, Better Singers than Sam and Amanda
Portland's Homes for Heroes program
Rosemary Anderson High School's Roberta Phillip Scholars
Mud, trees, and David Douglas High students
Frosty Trio
News from the Oregon Legislature, 3/21/11
Marshall's Last Princess
Update on Wireless Facilities in neighborhoods
Another example of the benefits of the Commission form of government : the JTTF debate
2011 Charter Commission convenes today, 1/24/11
Street Roots' Analysis on Ending Homelessness
Portland Police 2011 Awards Ceremony
Thank you for using my web site
Successful Second Sock Drive
Oregon Civil Rights Stories Project
Charter Commission, Part 1
FREE Street Stories Film Festival this weekend
Apply to be on the Oversight Committee for the Historical Society Levy
Children, Parents and Partners of Prisoners
Thankful for people with the Spirit of Portland
Portland Community Media Workshop on Digital Storytelling
Updated Information on Leaf Removal Options
Monday Nov 8 Veterans' event at Reynolds High School
Citizen Involvement Statistics from the Auditor's Annual Survey
Questions/concerns about the Leaf Collection program/fee?
Help Beaumont School win a $100k grant
New Record
Congratulations, Commissioner!
Sidewalk Management Citations data
Update on Alcohol Impact Area proposal
Beautiful Mural to combat Graffiti
Proposed Alcohol Impact Area
Opting out of receiving Phone Books
Cigarette butts are a problem
National Women's Health Week
Graffiti Grants announced in Southeast Uplift
My office philosophy
West Hayden Island Resolution 7/29/10
What to do with West Hayden Island?
Funding for basic emergency services
Community Service Volunteers
Uncut version of Wireless OpEd
Council Resolution on Arizona S.B. 1070
Weekend Update
Positive events in East Portland
Great Blue Heron Week
Saving money, sending money
G.R.E.A.T. Graffiti Cleanup
Nominate citizens for the Sy Award
Council Wellness Challenge Activities
Nominate Portlanders for the Governor's Volunteer Awards
Ruffled feathers
Proposed Amendments on Schools and Parks Code Project
Please sign up for the NAMI Walk, 5/23/10
Memorial Coliseum planning
Please cut our budget
Urban beauty
Vote every day, to win Google
Actions for improving community mental health care services
New members needed for the Portland Utility Review Board
Springtime in Portland
Portland's application to Google
Regional Graffiti work
Elder Friendly
$20 million "for bike projects from sewer rates"?
Additional Public Hearing on Independent Police Review changes
Working Waterfront
What you should know about the Census
Prescription Drug Turn-in event this Saturday
Ship Photography
Southeast Uplift wins Community Solar Leadership award
Community and Police Relations work
Working River
Statement on funding for MLS soccer
Filing Non-emergency Police Reports on line
Proud of Portland's 9-1-1 service
Register and Vote
Take a fire safety quiz and help Portland Fire & Rescue
City Superheroes Support Sock Solicitation
Hawthorne Bridge
Spirit of Portland Awards feedback requested
Your Voice requested, on community information technology
Frozen stiff
Safety and Fines on the Portland Mall
Crime Statistics from Multnomah County
Hollywood Veterans' Day Parade
Crime Prevention, Business Promotion, and Community Building in Overlook
Burnside Bridge
Guidance on when to seek medical care for flu symptoms
Coming Down The Pike
Cute Blazer Fan and Terry Porter
Lower Cost Comcast Cable Options
Osprey
Council Supports H.R. 676, National Health Care Act
Useful Police Services links
Useful Transportation and Street Services links
Oaks Bottom
Preparing for flu season
Sharing Public Spaces Report
Still Soaring
Comments on Transit Oriented Tax Abatement
Labor of Love and Landscaping in Lents
Prescription drug turn-in event
Our Urban Willamette
TriMet Passes for City Employees
Multnomah Days Parade, and more
Sign Up for Kids' Health Care today!
National Night Out parties
YWCA Fundraiser
Fisher
Comments on the Sharing Public Spaces meetings
Interesting Article on Portland Soccer funding
Conversing about Race
City Lights
Interested in the Rose Quarter?
Restorative Listening
Marquam Bridge
Women/Children's Health Survey
Division-Clinton Parade
Comments on Bull Run water treatment
Bull Run Watershed tour
Sunset
Comments on PGE Park deals
Recreational River
Yay for Portlanders!
Remember December?
Good discussion!
City of Roses
Comments on Soccer/Baseball
Sunrise
More Progress on Health Care
Thoughts on helping people living outside
Beautiful
Citizen Representative Needed
Comments on 39th/Chavez Street Renaming
Good in the Hood Parade
Good article on Neighborhood Associations
Help with Health Insurance Coverage
2009 Pride Parade
Help Affording Prescription Drugs
Renting and worried about foreclosure?
Starlight Parade
Resolution on Potential Health Impacts of Wireless Facilities
NAMI Walk
Progress on providing health care coverage for children
Parade season!
Short-term extension on Sidewalk Obstructions Ordinance
Roseway Mural Dedication
From Amanda's Mailbox, on Helping with Homelessness
Made in Oregon sign - update
World Water Day, Sunday 3/22
The Great Soccer Debate
City Council hearings
Columbia River Bridge Discussion
Westside Express Service
Radon Awareness Month - Radon in your home can kill you, and you don't need to move to fix the problem
Citizen Representatives needed - Bureau of Communications User Board
Go Blazers! - Amanda at the January 2nd Portland Trailblazers game
Visual breaks
Join my team
Barge Launch with Tom Sass