POL Government Elected Officials Commissioner Amanda Fritz Blog
The Great Soccer Debate - Printable Version - March 10, 2009 - 3 Comments

Mayor Adams and Commissioner Leonard have been working on a proposal to bring Major League Soccer to Portland, by remodeling PGE Park again and building a new, smaller stadium for the Beavers AAA baseball team.  That second stadium would be either where Memorial Coliseum stands, or in Lents Park.  Both the Portland Timbers and the Beavers are owned by Merritt Paulson, who has been working with my colleagues and a citizens' Task Force to reach a tentative deal.  Find all the Task Force information here.


The Task Force report recommends pursuing the two stadium deal, with conditions. It could be argued the conditions are not yet met in the proposals published so far. The Task Force does not recommend for the site of the second stadium, which is disappointing to me.  It is a key decision that should be factored in to the overall approval or denial of the project.  The Report also does not assess whether the proposed uses of resources and space will stimulate economic development, and if so, whether the proposed uses generate more economic development than other potential uses of the resources and space.


The preferred location of the soccer stadium is PGE Park, according to Mayor Adams.  The City still owes $28.3 million from the last renovation there. 


The proponents require creation of a new Urban Renewal District to borrow more money for the soccer improvements.  I am very troubled that the proper process for discussing creation of a new urban renewal district has not been followed to date.  The Portland Development Commission and the Planning Commission are supposed to hold public hearings to take testimony, before an urban renewal area is approved.  There would be almost no point in holding public hearings on that issue, if the Council decides new borrowing is needed at Wednesday's hearing on soccer.  Further, urban renewal districts divert money from the General Fund, schools, and County services.  The Task Force conditions call for no impact on the General Fund or basic services, but the proposed mechanism to fund PGE Park improvements doesn't meet that standard.  Urban renewal takes rising property tax revenue away from other funds.


I've received over 800 messages on this topic.  I have read every one, and replied to as many as time allowed this weekend (that darned "spring forward" thing stole an hour, chiz chiz).  Public opinion is running 2 to 1 against public funding for the stadium.  I don't make decisions based on the numbers of the 350,000+ registered Portland voters who ask me to vote for or against, but I do read and consider the input.  Thank you all for writing and calling my office.


Many of the messages in support are from people outside of Portland, from as far away as Britain, and a U.S. military captain in Europe.  While some of the outsiders are not Portland taxpayers, their support gives credence to the assertion the stadium improvements will increase tourism.  But then opponents have sent me links to research suggesting minimal improvement in visitors and local spending in relation to game days.  For instance, a study in Baltimore showed that although one third of attendees at Orioles games come from outside the city, the net benefit to the local economy is only $3 million/year.  Another study showed no significant change in local sales tax revenue during the baseball players' strike/lockout.


Here are some other interesting facts:


*  The City is still paying off debt from improvements in the Rose Quarter.  $23 million is owed, with the debt expected to retire in 2017.


*  The City is still paying off debt from improvements to PGE Park.  $28.3 million is owed, with the debt projected to be paid off in 2023. Note, some supporters have asserted that Merritt Paulson is currently paying down the PGE Park debt, but the Task Force report says on page 24 that the City and County are paying it.  Mr. Paulson just pays the rent and ticket taxes as per the lease agreement.


*  In the Rose Garden deal, the City put up $44 million, the Blazers and their owner, $230 millon.  The City funded only 16% in that project. 


*  The current annual lease for PGE Park is $825,000.  The lease for the new baseball stadium would be $666,000/year.  The lease on PGE Park with soccer improvements is set at $1 million/year.


*  The City currently pays $150,000 per year to Shortstop LLC (also owned by Merritt Paulson) to pass through to staff, to supplement the low wages paid to stadium workers. 


*  The median wage of the 200 full time workers (post construction) the project says will be created will be $32,000/year.  The latest deal does not set wages or expectations for wages.


*  The median wage of Major League Soccer players is $61,000.  At least $5 million in bonds is supposed to be paid off with diverted state income taxes on players' salaries.


*  Once operating, the City receives revenue from sports facilities from ticket sales tax (7% per ticket, up from the current 6%), and parking revenues (the City owns the parking garages at the Rose Quarter, and of course the meters near PGE Park).



To read a post on my old blog two years ago, establishing my soccer cred and raising an issue almost completely irrelevant to the current proposal, see Bend it like Beckham


For my partial list of concerns on this project last week, see Fritz calls foul.



Since I published those questions last week, more deals were made - and I have identified more challenges, which I will raise at the hearing Wednesday 3/11/09. 


I am holding true to my ongoing pledge that I do not make up my mind on issues before hearing the final proposals and all the public testimony. 


It should be a very interesting hearing.  Watch it live on Portland Community Media, cable Channel 30, if you can't come down to City Hall.


Please review our Code of Conduct rules before posting a comment to this site. Report Abuse, please include specific topic and comment for the fastest response/resolution.

Posted by: Andrew & James Farris & Thurlow - March 11, 2009 07:31 PM

With numbers like your posting here, it is amazing that anyone in their right mind, I mean not beholden to anyone in the private sector, could vote yes on this issue.
To use money that will be limited in this current economic crisis to build or finance something as trivial as a soccer venue reeks of insanity.
Our roads are some of the worst I have driven on, Trimet is calling for reduced service, and my property taxes see no end in going up and up each year.
This city is not a piggy bank for the rich and developers, yet it seems to be used that way. Why?
We have a Mayor with ethical issues, and an economy that is in dire straits. (great band though)
When speaking to your fellow council members, please remember that our tax dollars, and future income from fees ans the like, could be better used to reduce monthly bus passes for college student, better upkeep on our roads, and above all, perhaps some health clinics for the drug dependent.

Posted by: Amanda Fritz - March 11, 2009 11:15 PM

Thanks for your comments.  Mayor Adams and I are working with Multnomah County Chair Wheeler on community facilities for people with addictions and mental illnesses.  Having worked for 22 years in inpatient psychiatry, I am constantly thinking "how will this proposal affect people in need in our community?".  

I was disappointed in the outcome of the vote today.

Posted by: Molly Franks - May 03, 2009 05:08 PM

I want to add my name to the tally of people opposed to using Urban Renewal or other public funds to build a new stadium in the Rose Quarter. I live along Interstate Ave, and would far prefer our tax dollars being channeled to support schools, affordable housing, and other local services in this area and city-wide.

-molly franks

Post a Comment (Sign-In Required)

Blog Entries
Applications being accepted to join the Portland Parks Board
The Plan for ending Houselessness
Successful City Sock Drive 2015!
City Sock Drive 2015
Dog Whistle Politics
Portland Parks Foundation seeks new Executive Director
Hearing on SB 921, the Fritz-Fairchild Act, Monday April 6 at 1 p.m.
Speech on rejoining Joint Terrorism Task Force, 2/25/15
Apply to be on the Community Oversight Advisory Board
City Sock Drive
Give your input on a crucial contract NOW!
Volunteers needed for Tree Code Oversight Advisory Committee
Old Town Chinatown plans
Technology Oversight Committee Vacancy
Volunteers needed for Development Review Advisory Committee
How to schedule accommodations for meetings needing American Sign Language (ASL) interpreters
Portland's oversight of Landslide Hazards
Outstanding public school students win golf-related scholarships
Applications invited to join the Parks Board
Job opening for Compliance Officer/Community Liaison for the Police-Department of Justice Settlement Agreement
Mountain Biking in Forest Park and other Portland Parks
Forest Park Project Objective Screening Tool
Two new parks for East Portland
Volunteers needed for Golf Advisory Committee
Volunteers needed for Adjustment Committee and Historic Review Commission
Response to mistletoe selling without a permit
Winter Shelter options
Really really interesting statistics
Landlord Education Classes
Agreement reached on moving the historic Rayworth House
At-Large Members needed for Washington Park Transportation Management Association Board
Thoughts on Development Services and Parks, four weeks later
The Power of One
Speech at the vote on the City's 2013 - 14 budget
Response to Petition on Saving the Mounted Patrol
Reminder: Front desk job opening in my office, applications due Sunday 5 p.m.
Job opening in my Office
Portland Passes Protected Sick Leave ordinance
Volunteers needed for the Portland Utility Review Board
Draft Police Use of Force Policy revisions posted
Email of the Week, on gun violence
Comment period open for Regional Transportation investments
Foreclosure assistance that works
Earned Sick Leave forum and process
Earned Sick Leave Proposal
Lower cost Landline Phone Service, Cell and Internet Options
NW Parking Plan - Proposed Amendments
Thankful for Street Roots, and local businesses
Feast for Southeast on Thanksgiving Day
Comments regarding Department of Justice Settlement Agreement
City Budget Office, Next Steps
OHSU Magnet Celebration
City Budget Office proposal
City moves further into the 21st Century
Sunday Parkways in East Portland
Transit Tickets for Oct 3 Stand Down Day for Veterans
Statement on Appeal of Frashour ruling
Cascade Aids Project walk
Feeling suicidal? Don't call 9-1-1. Call 503-97-23456
Central City Concern Celebrates 40th Anniversary of Hooper Program
Recycling Facility Tour
The Big Float 2012
Golden Leaf Education Foundation Fundraiser
Honkin' Huge Burritos Day
City Commits to Formalize Relationships with Tribal Partners
Police Bureau Recruiting Community Police Officers
Submit Nominations for Awards! Plan a Party!
A family's experience with Autism
Help Prevent Homelessness for Larry
U.S. Conference of Mayors adopts Four Portland Initiatives
Expanded Coverage for Autism Treatment
City of Portland family's Kate Sinnott is Rose Festival Queen
Sunnyside Environmental School students visit City Hall
Community Empowerment Funding
Franklin HS graduation, and Kali Ladd on the City's Support for Education
Starlight Parade 2012
Comments on the new Urban Renewal Area for PSU
Visitors from Turkey
Promise Walk for Pre-eclampsia
Graffiti Cleanup with the 2012 Rose Festival Court
Lisa Jackson, EPA head, visits Portland
Why upcoming GirlStrength/WomenStrength classes matter
Congratulations, Portland Public Schools
NAMI Walk 2012
Walk to Work Day
2011 High School Graduation Rates
Buckman Pool - Budget meeting tonight
Chinese New Year Celebrations
Willamette Pedestrian Coalition Annual Meeting
Willamette River Recreation Strategy
PCC Future Connect Scholarship Program
Pirates of Madison High
President F.W. de Klerk's visit
Job openings in the 9-1-1 center
ANB Camp 49 Event
Publicizing Fundraisers
Introducing Dante J. James, Director of the Office of Equity and Human Rights
2011 By the Numbers - Report Card
East Portland Action Plan Annual Report
State Legislative Update 2/3/12
Piccolo Park Water Fountain Fundraiser
Love World Run
Earthquake Preparedness
Proposed Changes to the Portland Charter
Dr. Herman Frankel on the City Council's Corporate Personhood resolution
26th Annual Martin Luther King Jr. Skanner Foundation breakfast
TriMet budget survey
City Socks Drive Successful Again
56 days that changed my life
Iraqi Society of Oregon Cultural Integration Series Graduation
Great jobs in the Plumbers and Steamfitters trades
Hillsdale Mural Celebration
Poet Laureate Paulann Petersen
Willamette River Recreation Strategy - comments requested
Volunteers of America Home Free Event
Service Coordination Team Graduation
A young life lost - How you can help
Sisters of the Road Auction on now through Dec 1
Constitutional Rights of assembly and governance
Native American Heritage Month Marketplace
Patience and sleep-deprivation
City of Portland's bank use
Office of Equity and Human Rights Seeks Director - Job posting sent nationwide - please forward to qualified people who may be interested
Occupy Portland camps endanger vulnerable people
Central City Concern Homeless Action fundraiser
Emergency TEST this Wednesday Nov 9 - do NOT call 9-1-1
Spirit of Portland Awards
Clara Peoples, Mother of Junteenth in Portland
Margaret Carter PCC Technical Education Building Dedication
Standing on the Shoulders of Giants: Gretchen Kafoury
Occupy Portland
Letter Carriers Union Rally
Shine a Light on Addiction and Recovery
Changing Police policies and procedures
Please complete the Street Roots survey
City Internship, City Job
Improvements to the Time, Place and Manner ordinance governing liquor licensed establishments
Parkrose Centennial Celebration
Walk to End Alzheimers, Walk to Defeat ALS
Remembering 9/11/01, in Portland 2011
Gateway First Reponder Tribute and Citizen of the Year
Office of Equity Creation Hearing
Hispanic Metropolitan Chamber fundraiser dinner
Sunday in the sun
Saturdays are for Service
Portland should seek relief on EPA Drinking Water mandates
My vote against the bike rental project
Equity Office Creation Ordinance, Public Review Draft
Somali American Council of Oregon
MAX Red Line successful, Ten Years on
National Night Out
Delightful Sunday Events in SW, NE, SE and North Portland
Weeding the grounds, or building community pride?
East Portland Expo Extravaganza
World Cup Winners
Apply to Serve on the Public Involvement Advisory Council
BOEC User Board citizen members
Volunteers invited for Technology Oversight Committee, and for 2011 Charter Commission
Job Opening in my Office, and other City hiring opportunities
State Legislative Update 6/24/11
Knights of Rosaria
State Legislative Update 6/19/11
State Legislative Update 6/10/11
State Legislative Update, end of May
Information on the Clean and Safe Program, for May 2011
City opens 2011 Spirit of Portland Award nominations
SB 346: Common Sense protections for callers to 9-1-1
The 9-1-1 computer: On time, under budget, and it works
Op-Ed in Street Roots on Street Performers
Vote daily to help Capitol Hill School
Parade Season kicks off on 82nd Avenue of Roses
State Legislative Update 4/29/11
Comments on JTTF Vote 4/28/11
Mid-term statistics
Hollyrood Kindergartners Cuter, Better Singers than Sam and Amanda
Portland's Homes for Heroes program
Rosemary Anderson High School's Roberta Phillip Scholars
Mud, trees, and David Douglas High students
Frosty Trio
News from the Oregon Legislature, 3/21/11
Marshall's Last Princess
Update on Wireless Facilities in neighborhoods
Another example of the benefits of the Commission form of government : the JTTF debate
2011 Charter Commission convenes today, 1/24/11
Street Roots' Analysis on Ending Homelessness
Portland Police 2011 Awards Ceremony
Thank you for using my web site
Successful Second Sock Drive
Oregon Civil Rights Stories Project
Charter Commission, Part 1
FREE Street Stories Film Festival this weekend
Apply to be on the Oversight Committee for the Historical Society Levy
Children, Parents and Partners of Prisoners
Thankful for people with the Spirit of Portland
Portland Community Media Workshop on Digital Storytelling
Updated Information on Leaf Removal Options
Monday Nov 8 Veterans' event at Reynolds High School
Citizen Involvement Statistics from the Auditor's Annual Survey
Questions/concerns about the Leaf Collection program/fee?
Help Beaumont School win a $100k grant
New Record
Congratulations, Commissioner!
Sidewalk Management Citations data
Update on Alcohol Impact Area proposal
Beautiful Mural to combat Graffiti
Proposed Alcohol Impact Area
Opting out of receiving Phone Books
Cigarette butts are a problem
National Women's Health Week
Graffiti Grants announced in Southeast Uplift
My office philosophy
West Hayden Island Resolution 7/29/10
What to do with West Hayden Island?
Funding for basic emergency services
Community Service Volunteers
Uncut version of Wireless OpEd
Council Resolution on Arizona S.B. 1070
Weekend Update
Positive events in East Portland
Great Blue Heron Week
Saving money, sending money
G.R.E.A.T. Graffiti Cleanup
Nominate citizens for the Sy Award
Council Wellness Challenge Activities
Nominate Portlanders for the Governor's Volunteer Awards
Ruffled feathers
Proposed Amendments on Schools and Parks Code Project
Please sign up for the NAMI Walk, 5/23/10
Memorial Coliseum planning
Please cut our budget
Urban beauty
Vote every day, to win Google
Actions for improving community mental health care services
New members needed for the Portland Utility Review Board
Springtime in Portland
Portland's application to Google
Regional Graffiti work
Elder Friendly
$20 million "for bike projects from sewer rates"?
Additional Public Hearing on Independent Police Review changes
Working Waterfront
What you should know about the Census
Prescription Drug Turn-in event this Saturday
Ship Photography
Southeast Uplift wins Community Solar Leadership award
Community and Police Relations work
Working River
Statement on funding for MLS soccer
Filing Non-emergency Police Reports on line
Proud of Portland's 9-1-1 service
Register and Vote
Take a fire safety quiz and help Portland Fire & Rescue
City Superheroes Support Sock Solicitation
Hawthorne Bridge
Spirit of Portland Awards feedback requested
Your Voice requested, on community information technology
Frozen stiff
Safety and Fines on the Portland Mall
Crime Statistics from Multnomah County
Hollywood Veterans' Day Parade
Crime Prevention, Business Promotion, and Community Building in Overlook
Burnside Bridge
Guidance on when to seek medical care for flu symptoms
Coming Down The Pike
Cute Blazer Fan and Terry Porter
Lower Cost Comcast Cable Options
Council Supports H.R. 676, National Health Care Act
Useful Police Services links
Useful Transportation and Street Services links
Oaks Bottom
Preparing for flu season
Sharing Public Spaces Report
Still Soaring
Comments on Transit Oriented Tax Abatement
Labor of Love and Landscaping in Lents
Prescription drug turn-in event
Our Urban Willamette
TriMet Passes for City Employees
Multnomah Days Parade, and more
Sign Up for Kids' Health Care today!
National Night Out parties
YWCA Fundraiser
Comments on the Sharing Public Spaces meetings
Interesting Article on Portland Soccer funding
Conversing about Race
City Lights
Interested in the Rose Quarter?
Restorative Listening
Marquam Bridge
Women/Children's Health Survey
Division-Clinton Parade
Comments on Bull Run water treatment
Bull Run Watershed tour
Comments on PGE Park deals
Recreational River
Yay for Portlanders!
Remember December?
Good discussion!
City of Roses
Comments on Soccer/Baseball
More Progress on Health Care
Thoughts on helping people living outside
Citizen Representative Needed
Comments on 39th/Chavez Street Renaming
Good in the Hood Parade
Good article on Neighborhood Associations
Help with Health Insurance Coverage
2009 Pride Parade
Help Affording Prescription Drugs
Renting and worried about foreclosure?
Starlight Parade
Resolution on Potential Health Impacts of Wireless Facilities
Progress on providing health care coverage for children
Parade season!
Short-term extension on Sidewalk Obstructions Ordinance
Roseway Mural Dedication
From Amanda's Mailbox, on Helping with Homelessness
Made in Oregon sign - update
World Water Day, Sunday 3/22
The Great Soccer Debate
City Council hearings
Columbia River Bridge Discussion
Westside Express Service
Radon Awareness Month - Radon in your home can kill you, and you don't need to move to fix the problem
Citizen Representatives needed - Bureau of Communications User Board
Go Blazers! - Amanda at the January 2nd Portland Trailblazers game
Visual breaks
Join my team
Barge Launch with Tom Sass